4. Arkham City: GOTY
This is technically just a re-release with a second disc for all the downloadable content that came after Arkham City's original release last fall. Even so, Arkham City is considered one of the greatest games of all time, not just this console generation. If you didn’t don the cape and cowl last year, do it now with this spiffy Game of the Year version, which, on top of all that pricy DLC at no extra charge, comes with download codes for three Batman animated films. This is the perfect thing to tide you over until the Dark Knight Rises hits Blu Ray.