From bourbon to rye, real men understand the golden goodness in their glass.
Clare Risen 1 / 12
Everyone is drinking whiskey these days, but not everyone seems to know what it is. Most of us know that Scotch is, indeed, a whiskey. And some of us know that bourbon doesn’t have to be made in Kentucky. Beyond that, there’s confusion. What used to be made by a few mist-wrapped distilleries in Scotland and Kentucky is now made all over the world, from Taiwan to San Diego; what used to be distilled from a few familiar grains is now made with everything from amaranth to quinoa. Don’t let the diversity scare you: If you want to become a whiskey master, start with these basics.
Scotch Distilled from a mash of water, yeast, and malted barley and aged in oak barrels for at least three years, it can be a blend of whiskys from different distilleries, or it can be a “single malt,” made by just one. Single malts can come from anywhere, but they have to come from Scotland to earn the name Scotch. There are some great blends—Johnnie Walker Blue Label, for one—but single malts are the rage. Prices are skyrocketing, but great, inexpensive drams remain. Try The Balvenie DoubleWood 12 Year: nutty, creamy, and just $50.
Bourbon Made from mostly corn and aged in new oak barrels, most of it’s still made in Kentucky, but many of the newer, small-scale craft distilleries are located far beyond the Bluegrass State. Bourbon is still a great value: You can get Heaven Hill’s Elijah Craig 12, a brisk, dry whiskey with hints of cola and toast, for about $30.
Rye Like bourbon, except—as the name implies—it’s mostly rye, not corn. Rye was a staple drink in colonial days—George Washington owned one of the largest rye distilleries in America—but it almost died out after Prohibition. It’s making a comeback thanks to the notes. For a good rye, check out Sazerac, which is relatively mellow but packs a minty kick, for $27.
Every year Heaven Hill releases a limited-edition bottling of its Elijah Craig bourbon. This bourbon is full of complex flavors— notably baking spices and burnt sugar—befitting a whiskey that has spent 20 years on wood.
Everyone talks about the single malts from Macallan these days, but like Four Roses versus Pappy, many insiders prefer GlenDronach. This one’s finished in sherry barrels; look for fudge and stewed fruit notes.
Easier to find than the distillery’s “single-barrel limited edition,” this is a beautiful bourbon, with dark fruit notes over a little spice and cocoa. It’s often the insider’s pick over the trendier Pappy van Winkle.